SMTP REQUIRETLS
What is SMTP REQUIRETLS?
SMTP REQUIRETLS, defined in RFC 8689, lets a sender demand encrypted delivery for one message all the way to its destination, refusing to send rather than silently falling back to plaintext like ordinary STARTTLS. AdminKit's STARTTLS guide covers the related MTA-STS mechanism, which sets the same no-downgrade policy domain-wide instead.
By AdminKit team, Netbase JSC · Updated
REQUIRETLS, defined in RFC 8689 — also tracked on its IETF Datatracker page, and covered as a client-side TLS enforcement mechanism in NIST SP 800-177’s Trustworthy Email guidance — is an SMTP extension that lets the sender of a specific message demand TLS-protected delivery all the way to its final destination, instead of accepting the ordinary STARTTLS behavior of silently falling back to plaintext if encryption can’t be negotiated. A sending server adds the REQUIRETLS parameter to the MAIL FROM command for that message; every relay handling it afterward must then either deliver over a TLS session with a certificate it can validate — checked via DNSSEC or an MTA-STS policy (RFC 8461) — or refuse to send the message at all and return a non-delivery notification, rather than quietly downgrading to an unencrypted connection. This differs from MTA-STS, which is a domain publishing a standing policy that applies to all incoming mail; REQUIRETLS instead lets an individual sender enforce the same no-downgrade guarantee on a single outgoing message, which matters when the sender needs that guarantee but can’t control, or doesn’t know, whether the recipient domain has published an MTA-STS policy of its own. Postfix is one implementation: its configuration parameter reference documents a requiretls_enable setting for the REQUIRETLS verb in MAIL FROM and an smtp_requiretls_policy setting, available in Postfix 3.11 and later, that controls how its SMTP client enforces REQUIRETLS for messages received with the option. Support is still limited to senders and relays that have specifically implemented the extension.
SMTP REQUIRETLS is part of AdminKit’s email authentication cluster; the full AdminKit glossary lists other related terms.
Frequently asked questions
What does SMTP REQUIRETLS let a sender do?
Demand TLS-protected delivery all the way to a message's final destination, refusing to send rather than silently falling back to plaintext.
How does REQUIRETLS differ from MTA-STS?
MTA-STS is a domain-wide standing policy that applies to all incoming mail; REQUIRETLS instead lets an individual sender enforce the same no-downgrade guarantee on one outgoing message.
What happens if a relay cannot deliver a REQUIRETLS message over validated TLS?
It must refuse to send the message and return a non-delivery notification, rather than quietly downgrading to an unencrypted connection.
Is REQUIRETLS widely supported today?
No -- support is still limited to senders and relays that have specifically implemented the extension.